5 reasons cashmere is so expensive, and what the label on a coat doesn’t tell you

You can purchase a coat made of 100% cashmere for $500 this winter. You can also spend more than $4,000 on a cashmere coat. They both say 100% cashmere on the label.

Why is cashmere so expensive? And how can prices vary that drastically? Cashmere is a goat’s soft undercoat, and much of what determines the price tag occurs before a label is ever stitched inside.

Here are five factors that determine the cost of a cashmere coat, and what to look for when you’re shopping.

  1. One goat gives very little

Cashmere is the soft down fiber found under the goat’s winter coat. It is combed or sheared off the goat annually in the spring. The average goat only produces about 150 grams of cashmere (approximately one-third of a pound).

It generally takes four to six goats to harvest enough down for one sweater and 30 or more goats to harvest enough down for one overcoat. China and Mongolia produce the majority of the world’s cashmere.

  1. More than half of it is thrown away

What’s removed from the goat? Goat down, outer hair, grease and dirt. Only the goat down is cashmere. Estimated global production of raw clips is between 15 and 20 thousand tons per year. After removing the excess materials, there are only about 6,500 tons of clean fiber.

Nobody’s going to tell you how that sorting was done on the label, but your neck will inform you. When your neck starts itching … the horrible itching feeling … it’s usually due to the coarse hairs.

  1. The finest fiber costs more, and the label doesn’t grade it

In the United States, for fiber to be labeled cashmere, it must average 19 microns or less in diameter. No more than 3% can be coarser than 30 microns. To put that in perspective, a human hair is several times thicker. Fibers from the same goat that don’t meet the standard have to be labeled wool, according to the Federal Trade Commission.

That fineness is what separates the sheep from the goats, so to speak, in cashmere vs. wool: thinner fibers trap more air for their weight, and that’s why cashmere can keep you so warm without weighing you down. The best stuff averages between 14 and 15.5 microns, with fibers around 35 millimeters long (longer fibers pill less).

Both types of fiber get to wear the cashmere label. The test is simple: rub the sleeve against itself for a few seconds. If little balls form on the edge of the sleeve in the store, they’ll form on you at home.

  1. A cashmere coat takes heavy cloth and hand sewing

A sweater is knit. A coat is cut from woven cloth and uses many times more fiber. Many of the best coats are made of double-face cloth: two layers woven together as one, so the coat requires no lining. At every edge the layers are split, folded in and stitched by hand.

You can check this one. Open the coat. If there is no lining and the inside looks like the outside, it is double-face. Feel how heavy the cloth is in your hand.

  1. “Cashmere” on a label can mean very little cashmere

Read the numbers. The FTC requires percentages, so you can’t legally label something “cashmere blend,” but you can say it’s “80% wool, 20% cashmere.” There’s no leeway on a 100% claim, and technically “pashmina” doesn’t count as a name of a fiber that’s recognized by law.

Labels can lie too. Back in 2021 the Cashmere and Camel Hair Manufacturers Institute, a trade group, sued Amazon over garments listed as made of 100% cashmere that it claimed were actually acrylic and polyester. Later, in January 2023, it filed a similar suit against Etsy.

The difference between $500 and $4,000 is finer and longer fiber, more of it, and hand sewing. Fur trim adds to that. A furrier in Kastoria, Greece, called CASIANI lists its cashmere coats starting at about $2,450, and from about $4,300 with fox trim, at regular U.S. prices this November.

So, is cashmere worth it? Only if you’ve scrutinized what the label doesn’t tell you.