Key Factors to Check When Comparing Home Loan Offers

A home loan represents the largest debt most people ever carry. The difference between two seemingly similar offers can cost or save you $50,000+ over a standard 30-year term. Yet 47% of borrowers accept the first offer they receive, according to Consumer Financial Protection Bureau data.

The interest rate grabs attention, but it tells only part of the story. Fees, loan structure, lender policies, and prepayment terms all determine your actual cost of borrowing.

Interest Rate Structures: Fixed vs. Adjustable

Fixed-Rate Mortgages: Your rate stays constant throughout the entire loan term. A 6.5% rate on day one remains 6.5% on payment 360.

Adjustable-Rate Mortgages (ARMs): These start with a lower introductory rate (typically 0.5%–1% below fixed rates) for 5, 7, or 10 years. After that period, the rate adjusts based on a market index plus a margin.

Critical ARM specifications to verify:

Initial cap: Maximum first adjustment (usually 2%–5%)
Periodic cap: Maximum each subsequent adjustment (typically 2%)
Lifetime cap: Maximum total increase (commonly 5%–6%)
Index used: SOFR, Treasury, or other benchmark
Margin: The fixed percentage added to the index (1.5%–3%)

A 5/1 ARM at 5.5% with a 5% lifetime cap means your worst-case scenario is 10.5%. Calculate monthly payments at that ceiling rate before signing.

APR vs. Interest Rate: Decoding the True Cost

The Annual Percentage Rate includes both interest and mandatory lender fees, expressed as a yearly cost. Federal law requires this disclosure for direct comparisons.

Fee components typically included in APR:

Fee Type	Typical Range
Origination fee	0.5%–1% of loan amount
Discount points	1 point = 1% of loan, reduces rate by ~0.25%
Underwriting fee	$400–$900
Processing fee	$300–$500
Document preparation	$50–$400

What APR excludes: Title insurance, appraisal, home inspection, property taxes, homeowner’s insurance.

Comparison example: Lender A: 6.25% interest, $12,000 fees → 6.58% APR Lender B: 6.5% interest, $3,000 fees → 6.62% APR

Lender A’s lower rate costs more upfront. The break-even point where those extra fees pay off through lower monthly payments is approximately 6.5 years. Plan to sell or refinance sooner? Lender B wins.

Loan Term Impact on Total Interest

The standard 30-year mortgage keeps payments manageable but maximizes interest paid. Shorter terms slash total cost dramatically.

$400,000 loan at 6.75% comparison:

Term	Monthly P&I	Total Interest	Interest Saved vs. 30-Year
30-year	$2,594	$534,040	—
20-year	$3,039	$329,360	$204,680
15-year	$3,539	$237,020	$297,020

The 15-year option requires $945 more monthly but saves nearly $300,000 over the loan’s life. Some lenders offer 10-year, 25-year, or custom terms—ask specifically.

Down Payment Thresholds and PMI

Putting down less than 20% triggers Private Mortgage Insurance requirements on conventional loans. This protects the lender, not you.

PMI cost factors:

Credit score (higher score = lower PMI)
Down payment percentage
Loan type and property type
PMI structure chosen (monthly, single premium, lender-paid)

Typical PMI rates: 0.3%–1.5% of original loan amount annually

On a $350,000 loan, that’s $1,050–$5,250 per year added to your costs.

PMI removal rules for conventional loans:

Automatic cancellation at 78% LTV (based on original value)
Borrower-requested removal at 80% LTV (may require new appraisal)
Some loans allow removal based on current market value after 2 years

FHA loans carry Mortgage Insurance Premium (MIP) for the life of the loan unless you put down 10%+ initially (then it’s 11 years).

Closing Cost Breakdown and Negotiation Points

Closing costs typically run 2%–5% of the purchase price. Some are fixed, others negotiable.

Non-negotiable costs:

Government recording fees
Transfer taxes (state/county dependent)
Prepaid property taxes and insurance

Negotiable costs:

Origination fees: Request reduction or waiver
Title insurance: Shop separately from lender’s recommendation
Attorney fees: Get multiple quotes in states requiring attorneys
Application fees: Some lenders waive these entirely

Seller concessions: Depending on market conditions, sellers may agree to pay 2%–6% of closing costs. This preserves your down payment but may require a higher purchase price to compensate.

Prepayment Terms and Flexibility

Prepayment penalties restrict your ability to pay off the loan early. While less common on primary residence mortgages post-2014, they still appear on investment properties, jumbo loans, and some subprime products.

Questions to ask every lender:

Is there a prepayment penalty? For how long? How much?
Can I make extra principal payments without fees?
What’s the maximum annual prepayment without triggering penalties?
Does biweekly payment scheduling cost extra?

Recasting provisions: Some lenders allow you to recast your loan after making a large lump-sum payment. This recalculates your monthly payment based on the new balance while keeping your original interest rate and term. Typically costs $150–$300 versus thousands for refinancing.

Lender Service Quality Indicators

You’ll interact with your mortgage servicer for 15–30 years. Poor service creates problems during escrow disputes, hardship requests, or simple payment questions.

Research methods:

CFPB complaint database: Search by company name for complaint volume and patterns
D. Power mortgage servicer satisfaction rankings
State attorney general complaint records
BBB ratings and response patterns

Retention vs. sale policies: Ask directly if the lender services loans in-house or sells servicing rights. Sold loans may transfer multiple times, each with a new company to deal with.

Loan Estimate Comparison Protocol

Federal regulations require lenders to provide a standardized Loan Estimate within three business days of application. This document enables direct comparison.

Page-by-page comparison checklist:

Page 1: Loan amount, interest rate, monthly payment, estimated total closing costs, cash to close

Page 2: Loan costs (origination charges, services you cannot shop for, services you can shop for), other costs, total closing costs

Page 3: Five-year cost comparison, APR, Total Interest Percentage (TIP)

Request Loan Estimates from a minimum of three lenders—five is better. Apply to all within a 14-day window to minimize credit score impact (multiple mortgage inquiries count as one).

Rate Lock Strategy

Interest rates fluctuate daily. A rate lock guarantees your quoted rate for a specific period, typically 30–60 days.

Lock considerations:

Longer locks cost more (higher rate or fee)
Float-down options allow you to benefit from rate drops (usually 0.125%–0.25% fee)
Lock expiration before closing requires renegotiation at current rates
Some lenders offer free 90-day locks on new construction

Time your lock based on realistic closing timeline plus a 7–10 day buffer.

Smart Borrowers Do This

Mortgage comparison demands more than rate shopping. Pull your credit reports 60 days before applying to correct errors. Calculate total loan cost at years 5, 10, and full term—not just monthly payments. Read the fine print on prepayment terms. Verify servicer reputation. Then negotiate from a position of knowledge, not hope.