Cold and Flu Season: Why Most Coughs Do Not Need an Antibiotic

Every winter, many patients who have been coughing for a week expect to leave the clinic with a prescription. In most cases an antibiotic would not help them. Public health agencies have warned for years that a large share of antibiotic prescriptions for respiratory complaints in outpatient care are unnecessary, and that the habit carries costs for the individual patient as well as for everyone else.

Viruses cause most respiratory infections

The common cold, influenza, most sore throats and nearly all cases of acute bronchitis in otherwise healthy adults are caused by viruses. Antibiotics act on bacteria. They have no effect on viruses and do not shorten a cold.

Two common beliefs keep the demand alive. One is that green or yellow mucus signals a bacterial infection. Color changes are a normal part of the immune response and occur in viral illness too. The other is that a cough lasting more than a few days must need treatment. The cough of acute bronchitis can last up to three weeks.

When antibiotics are the right choice

Some respiratory infections are bacterial and do need treatment. Strep throat is one example, which is why clinicians confirm it with a rapid test or throat culture rather than by appearance alone. Bacterial pneumonia is another, as is whooping cough. Sinus infections are usually viral, but antibiotics may be considered when symptoms are severe, last more than about ten days without improvement, or worsen again after starting to get better.

A clinical overview of how upper and lower infections are distinguished and treated is available in this article on respiratory tract infection treatment.

The cost of an unnecessary prescription

Antibiotics are not harmless. Side effects range from rash and diarrhea to severe allergic reactions. They also disturb the normal bacteria of the gut, which can allow Clostridioides difficile to cause serious intestinal infection. On a larger scale, every course of antibiotics gives bacteria a chance to develop resistance, making future infections harder to treat.

What helps in the meantime

For viral infections, treatment aims at comfort: rest, fluids and, where appropriate, over-the-counter medicines for fever and pain. Honey can ease a cough in adults and in children over one year of age. Over-the-counter cough and cold medicines are not recommended for young children. For influenza and COVID-19, antiviral drugs are available for people at higher risk, and they work best when started early.

Signs that need medical attention

  • difficulty breathing or shortness of breath,
  • fever that lasts more than a few days or returns after improving,
  • symptoms that last longer than about ten days without getting better,
  • chest pain, confusion or signs of dehydration,
  • any fever in an infant younger than three months.

People with chronic lung or heart disease, weakened immune systems or advanced age should seek advice earlier. Vaccination against influenza, COVID-19 and, for eligible groups, RSV and pneumococcal disease reduces the risk of severe illness in the first place.

This article is for general information and does not replace individual medical advice.