Common Legal Mistakes First-Time Founders Make When Starting a U.S. Company

Most initial legal problems arise from five gaps: a tax situation not set up properly, neglected federal forms, neglected state forms, commingling of business and personal funds, and operating agreements not properly executed. All five gaps can be resolved by an LLC compliance checklist. Ignoring it can result in a revoked/suspended status, legal action, and loss of limited liability protection.

Setting up an LLC is easy, as it requires only a state filing and a fee. However, the real problems start with maintaining good standing. The checklist can be built once and then reviewed annually. Tasks associated with federal laws are labeled as such; the rest are state-specific. Confirm with your Secretary of State. There are provisions that affect non-U.S. founders more, and those are noted.

Why is it risky to commingle business and personal funds?

An LLC (or any entity, for that matter) will protect personal assets only if it is treated as a separate entity. If funds are commingled, a court can disregard that entity and look through the funds to make a judgment. The doctrine is piercing the corporate veil, and how it is applied varies from state to state.

The situation may appear innocuous. Stripe payouts may be deposited into a personal account, and business expenses may be paid via a personal credit card.

You will need your EIN and formation documents to open your business bank account. Once you have your bank account, you will use it to pay the costs of running your business. You will take money out as an owner’s draw or distribution. Keep good bookkeeping, and you will have a clean trail, making tax time a lot less stressful.

What is the federal tax classification of your LLC?

By default, a single-member LLC is disregarded for federal tax purposes, and a U.S. individual reports the income on Schedule C of Form 1040. An LLC with two or more members is treated as a partnership, files Form 1065 by the 15th of March each year, and issues each member a Schedule K-1.

The “LLC handles its own taxes” thought process is common. So, failing to file Form 2553 in a timely fashion to make an S-Corp election. The due date is 2 months and 15 days after the start of the tax year you are electing. Relief is available for late elections, but there are conditions, so don’t plan on this.

There is a cost for missing a partnership tax return. The IRS charges a penalty per partner per month for up to 12 months, and the amount is reflected in the Form 1065 instructions. Check to see what the current rate is before guessing the exposure.

Will a foreign-owned LLC trigger additional filings with the IRS?

Yes, a single-member LLC owned by a foreign person is disregarded by the IRS for income tax purposes and is required to file a U.S. income tax return (Form 1120 or Form 7004) and attach Form 5472 (a proxy return). It is due on April 15, and the due date has been extended to October 15 by filing Form 7004.

Form 5472 is specifically designed to collect information regarding activities and transactions involving a foreign person. The penalty for not filing Form 5472 is $25,000 for each year in which it is not filed, and the penalty is applied even if the LLC had no income during that year. A founder who established an LLC, had no sales, and did not file anything can still be liable.

The issuance of an Employer Identification Number (EIN) by the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) is the first step many foreign founders take. The IRS issues EINs at no cost. EINs are issued in the name of a responsible party and can be issued only once per responsible party per day. CP 575 is sent by the IRS to the entity (with the EIN issued) and should be retained. It may be requested by banks and payment processors.

Does your business need to submit a beneficial ownership report?

Not if your LLC was formed in the U.S. The Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) issued a final rule on August 11, 2020, that exempts U.S.-formed entities and U.S. persons from reporting beneficial ownership information (BOI) under the Corporate Transparency Act (CTA). There are many older checklists and sales emails that describe a BOI deadline, so review the date on any of these documents before paying to have a report filed.

There are two exceptions to this rule. First, foreign entities registered to do business in the U.S. that are not U.S. entities must submit a report. Second, financial institutions (banks, for example) are required to collect beneficial ownership information as part of their Customer Due Diligence (CDD) obligations, and therefore will ask you for this information when you open a business bank account. Confirm the status on FinCEN’s website, since there is the potential for litigation of the rule. Business news sites such as Big News Network are also useful for following general business and regulatory headlines. 

What state requirements belong on an LLC compliance checklist?

There are typically surprises at the state level, and each state can create its own rules.

Taxes and reports. Delaware charges LLCs an annual tax of $300, due on June 1. California charges a minimum annual tax of $800, whether the LLC is profitable or not. Other states charge only a report fee. Failure to file on time results in a late fee. Repeated failure to file can result in the state administratively dissolving or revoking the LLC.

Foreign qualification. Forming an LLC in Delaware or Wyoming does not exempt you from the state where you live and work. If you are working and/or doing business in a different state from the state in which you formed an LLC, you are generally required to foreign-qualify in that state and pay that state’s fees.

Registered agent. Every state requires a registered agent with a physical address in the state who is available during normal business hours. Failure to have a registered agent can result in a default judgment in a lawsuit. Some founders outsource recurring state filings and registered agent duties to a service that helps maintain LLC compliance. 

Operating agreement. An LLC operating agreement is a document that outlines the inner workings of an LLC and is legally non-binding, meaning it can be modified at any time. Federal law does not require an operating agreement; however, some state laws do. New York requires an LLC operating agreement within 90 days of forming the LLC. A single-member LLC should benefit from a signed operating agreement that outlines ownership and how profits will be treated.

Sales tax. SaaS and other digital products become taxable in the state where the consumer is located, not the state where the seller is located. Certain states have economic nexus thresholds. To determine whether a state has an economic nexus threshold and, if so, what it is, visit that state’s Department of Revenue website.

What should be included on a practical LLC compliance checklist?

  • Do you have a business bank account and card?
  • Have you saved your EIN confirmation letter (CP 575)?
  • Have you signed your operating agreement?
  • Have you confirmed your tax classification? Do you know the deadline for your Form 1065? What about Forms 5472 and 1120 and pro forma? What about your deadline for filing Form 2553?
  • Do you know the due date for your state’s annual report?
  • Have you made sure your registered agent is current in all states?
  • Have you made sure you’re foreign-qualified in all states?
  • Have you retained receipts for the last three years?

What other mistakes cost first-time founders money?

  • Have you personally signed any contracts? Sign as “Your Company, LLC, by Your Name, Member.”
  • Are you ignoring IRS notices? Responding to a notice is your best defense against liability. Notices can also be sent to the wrong address.
  • Do you think the formation of your LLC is the final filing? Every year, you’ll need to file an annual report and possibly pay taxes.

What should you do this week?

Add all of the above dates to your calendar and set a reminder two weeks in advance. Next, check your state’s Secretary of State site for more information. If you operate a business in a different state from the one in which you formed your LLC, check that state’s site first.

The IRS and your state’s Secretary of State site are the best places to find information on common deadlines and forms.