Enclosed Pools vs Traditional Covers: What’s the Real Difference?

If you’ve ever owned a pool, you know the drill: every season brings leaves, bugs, dust, and unpredictable weather. Most people start with a basic tarp or vinyl cover — and quickly realize it’s not enough. That’s where enclosed pools come in.

But what’s the actual difference between a traditional pool cover and a full enclosure? Is it just about looks, or is there more to it?

Let’s break it down.

🧊 Traditional Covers: Cheap, But Limited

Soft covers — whether vinyl, mesh, or tarp — are designed to keep debris out. That’s about it. They’re:

  • Affordable
  • Easy to install
  • Lightweight

But they also:

  • Tear easily
  • Trap water and dirt
  • Blow off in strong winds
  • Offer zero insulation
  • Don’t protect kids or pets

They’re fine for short-term use, but not ideal for long-term comfort or safety.

🏠 What Makes an Enclosed Pool Different?

An enclosed pool uses a structural cover — often made of aluminum and polycarbonate — that fully surrounds the pool. It’s more than a lid; it’s a protective space.

Here’s what you get:

  • Weather protection: Rain, snow, wind — no problem
  • Heat retention: Swim longer, spend less on heating
  • Safety: Acts as a barrier for children and pets
  • Cleanliness: No more daily skimming
  • Aesthetic upgrade: Looks sleek, adds value

And if you choose a retractable pool cover, you get flexibility: open it on sunny days, close it when the weather turns.

Want to see how retractable systems work? Check out Aquashield’s retractable pool cover options — built for real-life weather and real-life backyards.

🛠️ Above Ground Pools: Can They Be Enclosed?

Absolutely. Many homeowners assume enclosures are only for inground pools, but that’s not true. You can install a dome-style or low-profile structure over an above ground pool — especially if you’re looking for a hard pool cover for an above ground pool that actually lasts.

These covers:

  • Prevent sagging and collapse
  • Stay in place during storms
  • Reduce evaporation and chemical loss
  • Make your pool usable in more seasons

For durable, fixed solutions, explore Aquashield’s non-retractable enclosure options — ideal for above ground setups and long-term protection.

🤔 FAQ: What Pool Owners Ask

Q: Are enclosures permanent? A: Not necessarily. Retractable models offer flexibility, while fixed ones are more low-maintenance.

Q: Do they block sunlight? A: No — most use UV-stable clear panels that let in light while insulating heat.

Q: Are they safe for kids? A: Yes. They act as a physical barrier and can be locked for added security.

Q: Will it fit my pool shape? A: Most enclosures are custom-built to match your pool’s dimensions and layout.

🧠 Final Thoughts

If you’re tired of battling the elements, replacing flimsy covers, or worrying about safety, it might be time to upgrade. An enclosed pool isn’t just a luxury — it’s a smart investment in comfort, cleanliness, and peace of mind.

Whether you go retractable or fixed, inground or above ground, the right enclosure transforms your pool from seasonal to sensational.

🌿 How to Choose the Right Pool Enclosure for Your Backyard

Adding a pool enclosure isn’t just about covering water — it’s about transforming your outdoor space into something more usable, more beautiful, and more protected. But with so many options out there, how do you choose the right one for your backyard?

Whether you’re building a new pool or upgrading an existing one, this guide will help you navigate the choices and make a smart, lasting investment.

To explore different pool enclosures and see what’s possible, start with real-world examples from trusted manufacturers.

🏠 Step 1: Know Your Pool Type

Your pool’s structure plays a big role in what kind of enclosure works best:

  • Inground pools offer the most flexibility — from full walk-in enclosures to sleek retractable designs
  • Above ground pools often benefit from dome-style or low-profile covers
  • Custom-shaped pools may require tailored engineering and modular designs

If you’re unsure, a quick consultation can save you time and help avoid costly mistakes.

🔄 Step 2: Choose Between Fixed and Retractable

This is one of the biggest decisions. Here’s how they compare:

  • Fixed enclosures are static and always closed. They’re low-maintenance, often more budget-friendly, and ideal for full-season coverage.
  • Retractable enclosures slide open and closed, giving you flexibility to enjoy open-air swimming when the weather is nice. They’re perfect for changing seasons and offer a dynamic, modern look.
  • If you want control and versatility, go retractable. If simplicity and durability are your priority, fixed might be better.

🧱 Step 3: Consider Height and Style

Enclosures come in different profiles:

  • Low-profile: Discreet and aerodynamic, great for heat retention
  • Mid-height: Allows partial standing, balances space and insulation
  • Walk-in/full-height: Turns your pool into a sunroom — ideal for entertaining and lounging

Think about how you’ll use the space. Do you want to swim only? Or relax, host, and enjoy the area year-round?

🌳 Step 4: Match Your Landscape

A pool enclosure should complement your backyard, not clash with it. Consider:

  • Roof shape: arched, flat, angular
  • Panel transparency: clear, tinted, UV-filtered
  • Frame color: match your home or garden tones
  • Integration: pathways, lighting, seating areas

A well-designed enclosure blends into your landscape and adds visual value — not just function.

🛠️ Step 5: Choose a Trusted Manufacturer

This part matters more than most people think. A poorly built enclosure can lead to leaks, drafts, or even structural issues. Look for:

  • Proven experience
  • Custom design capabilities
  • Clear warranties
  • Local references

Aquashield is one of the most trusted names in the industry, offering pool enclosures for inground pools and above ground setups — all engineered for real-life weather and long-term durability.

🤔 FAQ: What Homeowners Ask

Q: Will an enclosure block sunlight? A: Not necessarily. Most use UV-stable clear panels that let in light while insulating heat.

Q: Can I open it partially? A: Yes — retractable models allow full or partial opening depending on your needs.

Q: Is it safe for kids and pets? A: Absolutely. Enclosures act as physical barriers and can be locked for added security.

Q: Will it increase my property value? A: In most cases, yes — especially if it adds year-round usability and visual appeal.

🧠 Final Thoughts

Choosing the right pool enclosure is about more than just covering water — it’s about creating a space that fits your lifestyle, your climate, and your long-term goals. Ask the right questions, explore your options, and work with a team that understands both design and durability.

Your backyard deserves more than a tarp. It deserves a structure that works, lasts, and looks amazing.

Similar Posts