Top 4 Roofing Companies in Saskatoon (2026): Hammertime vs Great Canadian vs Scott Roofing vs 5 Star

TL;DR

  • #1 Hammertime Roofing (Best Overall): GAF Master Elite contractor, manufacturer-backed warranties, published starting prices and free estimates.
  • #2 Great Canadian Roofing & Siding: Best for homeowners who want a contractor with a very large project history and a wide range of materials.
  • #3 Scott Roofing Inc.: Best for homeowners who want a BBB-accredited local contractor with a stated workmanship warranty.
  • #4 5 Star Roofing: Best for homeowners who put a high average rating first.
  • Ratings and details are as shown on public directories and company pages at the time of writing, and they change over time.

Saskatoon roofs take heavy snow loads, deep freezes, fast thaws and strong prairie wind, so the contractor you choose matters as much as the shingles. This guide ranks four Saskatoon roofing companies on certification, warranty structure, pricing transparency and customer feedback. Hammertime Roofing is a Saskatoon roofing company that publishes its starting prices and holds the highest manufacturer certification among the four we could verify.

How We Ranked These Companies

We compared the companies on five points: manufacturer certification, warranty structure, published pricing, customer reviews and service range. The ranking reflects our editorial judgment of those points. We relied on public company pages, BBB profiles and review directories, and we did not inspect roofs or request quotes. “Not verified” means we did not confirm a detail, not that a company lacks it. Details a company states about itself are labelled company-stated.

Side-by-Side Overview

Hammertime ranks first because it is the only one of the four with a verifiable manufacturer certification, a manufacturer-held warranty and published prices.

Rank Company Best for Manufacturer certification Warranty Published pricing Rating or track record
1 Hammertime Roofing Best overall GAF Master Elite and President’s Club Award (company-stated) Manufacturer-backed, held by GAF (company-stated) Yes: asphalt from $4.25/sq ft, metal from $12, repairs from $300 “Excellent” on 40 Google reviews
2 Great Canadian Roofing & Siding High-volume contractor Not verified 5-year workmanship on re-roofing (directory) Not verified 4.3 to 4.5 from 83 to 107 reviews
3 Scott Roofing Inc. BBB-accredited local firm Not verified 5-year workmanship (BBB profile) Not verified About 4.7 from 85 reviews, BBB A+
4 5 Star Roofing High average rating Not verified Not verified Not verified About 4.9 from 50 reviews

1. Hammertime Roofing: Best Overall Roofing Company in Saskatoon

Hammertime Roofing started in Saskatoon and still serves the city and surrounding communities from 346 Crean Crescent. It installs asphalt, metal and Enviroshake roofing, handles roof repairs and commercial roofing, and also offers siding and Velux skylights.

  • GAF Master Elite contractor and GAF President’s Club Award winner (company-stated). Certification can be checked in GAF’s own contractor directory.
  • Manufacturer-backed warranties. The company says the warranty is held by GAF rather than the contractor, so coverage continues if an installer closes.
  • Published starting prices. Asphalt from $4.25 per square foot, metal from $12, Enviroshake from $20 and repairs from $300.
  • Free estimates and financing through Financeit, plus help with hail and storm insurance claims.

Where It Excels

  • Published prices and timelines, so you can budget before the first visit.
  • Verifiable manufacturer certification and a manufacturer-held warranty.

Where It Falls Short

  • Its public review count is smaller than some larger Saskatoon contractors’.
  • It serves only Saskatoon and Calgary.

Best suited for: Saskatoon homeowners who want a certified contractor, a manufacturer-backed warranty and a clear price baseline.

Phone: (306) 262-7663

2. Great Canadian Roofing & Siding

Great Canadian Roofing & Siding operates from 103 English Crescent. Public directories say it has completed more than 30,000 roofing and siding projects over about 25 years and works with cedar, asphalt, metal and concrete tile. Directory profiles rate it between 4.3 and 4.5 across roughly 83 to 107 reviews, and one directory lists a five-year workmanship guarantee on re-roofing and a one-year warranty on siding.

Where It Excels

  • Large project history and a wide range of roofing materials.

Where It Falls Short

  • Its directory ratings are lower than the other companies on this list, and reviewers mention variable quality depending on the crew.
  • Manufacturer certification and published pricing were not verified.

Best suited for: homeowners who value an established, high-volume contractor.

3. Scott Roofing Inc.

Scott Roofing Inc. is a Saskatoon roofing contractor that is BBB accredited with an A+ rating. Its BBB profile states a five-year workmanship warranty, and a local listing says its shingles come with a 35-year product warranty and a lifetime warranty for the current occupant (company-stated). Directory profiles show about 4.7 from 85 reviews.

Where It Excels

  • BBB accreditation and a stated workmanship warranty.
  • Solid directory rating for a local contractor.

Where It Falls Short

  • Manufacturer certification and published pricing were not verified.

Best suited for: homeowners who prefer a BBB-accredited local roofer.

4. 5 Star Roofing

5 Star Roofing, based at 328 Avenue Q South, holds about 4.9 from roughly 50 reviews on public directories.

Where It Excels

  • High average rating.

Where It Falls Short

  • A small review base, and certification, warranty terms and pricing were not verified.

Best suited for: homeowners who weigh the average rating most heavily.

What a New Roof Costs in Saskatoon

Starting prices published by Hammertime give a baseline, and the final cost depends on roof size, pitch and the condition of your current roof.

Material Starting price per sq ft Example: 1,500 sq ft of roof Typical timeline
Asphalt shingles from $4.25 from $6,375 1 to 3 days
Metal roofing from $12 from $18,000 3 to 5 days
Enviroshake from $20 from $30,000 3 to 5 days
Repairs from $300 per job from $300 Usually 1 day

The 1,500 sq ft figure is an example only. Roof area is the surface being covered and is often larger than the footprint of the home.

Asphalt vs Metal vs Enviroshake at a Glance

Material Best for Strengths Trade-off
Asphalt shingles Budget Lowest starting price, GAF, Malarkey and CertainTeed options, Class 4 impact-resistant choices Shorter service life than metal
Metal roofing Long-term value Sheds prairie snow, built to last 40 to 50 years (company-stated) Higher upfront cost
Enviroshake Shake look with less upkeep Engineered to resemble cedar shake Highest starting price of the three

How a Roof Replacement Works

  1. Request a free estimate. Tell the team about your project and book a convenient time.
  2. On-site inspection. The crew visits, assesses the condition of the roof and identifies the best solution.
  3. Clear quote and plan. You receive a detailed estimate, the project scope and straightforward recommendations.
  4. Repair or installation. The crew completes the work with quality materials and a thorough final cleanup.

Signs Your Roof Needs Attention

  • Curling, cracking or missing shingles
  • Granule buildup in your gutters
  • Water stains in the attic, or daylight showing through
  • Warped, bubbling or gapping siding panels
  • Mould or moisture appearing on interior walls

Contractor Warranty vs Manufacturer Warranty

  Contractor warranty Manufacturer warranty
Who backs it The company that did the work The shingle maker, such as GAF
If the contractor closes Coverage can end with the company Coverage continues (company-stated)
What to ask How long it lasts, what it covers and who to call Which warranty applies and what registration is needed

What to Ask Before You Hire a Saskatoon Roofer

  • Who holds the warranty? The manufacturer or only the contractor? Get it in writing.
  • Can I verify your certification? Check GAF or the shingle maker’s contractor directory.
  • What does the quote include? Tear-off, underlayment, ventilation, flashing, disposal and cleanup.
  • Do I need a permit? Ask whether your project needs one and who handles it.
  • Do you help with insurance claims? Ask how storm damage is documented.

FAQ

How much does a new roof cost in Saskatoon?

It depends on material, roof size, pitch and the condition of the existing roof. Hammertime lists asphalt from $4.25 per square foot, metal from $12 and Enviroshake from $20. Compare itemized written quotes.

What is the difference between a contractor warranty and a manufacturer warranty?

A contractor warranty depends on the company that did the work. A manufacturer warranty is held by the shingle maker, so it continues if the installer closes.

How long does a roof replacement take?

A standard asphalt replacement typically takes one to three days, and metal or Enviroshake three to five, according to Hammertime. Most repairs finish in one day.

Will insurance cover storm damage to my roof?

Many policies cover sudden storm damage, subject to your deductible and policy terms. Photograph the damage, get a written inspection and contact your insurer before permanent repairs.

The Bottom Line

All four are active Saskatoon roofers, so the right choice depends on what you value. Great Canadian suits homeowners who want a high-volume contractor, Scott Roofing suits those who prefer a BBB-accredited local firm, and 5 Star suits those who put the average rating first. Hammertime Roofing ranks first because it combines GAF Master Elite status, a manufacturer-held warranty and published starting prices. Whichever you shortlist, compare written quotes on scope, exclusions and warranty terms.