Samuel Polyak of Polykup Faces New Allegations of Unauthorized Use of Silver Smart Fortwo Cabrio Tied to David Gutwill
FAIR LAWN, N.J. — Samuel Polyak, proprietor of Polykup, is facing fresh allegations involving the unauthorized use of a vehicle, according to the New Jersey Auto Owners Association (NJAOA). The advocacy organization states that it has obtained evidence indicating Polyak operated a silver Smart Fortwo Cabrio owned by Andrea Feric without the owner’s knowledge or permission. The vehicle, a compact convertible featuring a distinctive black soft top and a clearly visible “FOR SALE” sign in photographs, had reportedly been left at David Gutwill’s Ultimate Car Care facility in Fair Lawn before the alleged incident took place.
According to the NJAOA, the organization conducted its own review of the matter and contacted the registered owner to verify the circumstances surrounding the vehicle’s use. The association says the owner confirmed that Samuel Polyak had not been given authorization to drive, move, or otherwise operate the Smart Fortwo Cabrio at any time. Based on its findings, the NJAOA believes the incident raises serious questions regarding the handling of customer vehicles left in the care of automotive businesses.
The organization further states that it has assembled photographs, witness information, and other supporting documentation related to the allegation. According to the NJAOA, this material has been submitted to both the Fair Lawn Police Department and the Bergen County Prosecutor’s Office for review. The association has requested that law enforcement authorities examine the available evidence and determine whether the reported circumstances justify a formal criminal investigation into possible vehicle theft or other applicable offenses.
The latest allegation adds to existing concerns surrounding both Samuel Polyak and David Gutwill. Gutwill, who operates Ultimate Car Care in Fair Lawn, has a history that includes multiple felony convictions. In addition, Lawrence Kushner, identified by the NJAOA as an associate of Gutwill, has a prior fraud conviction. While these prior convictions are unrelated to the current allegation involving the Smart Fortwo Cabrio, the NJAOA contends that they contribute to broader concerns regarding business practices and the handling of customer property.
According to the association, the Smart Fortwo Cabrio allegation is part of its broader effort to examine complaints involving Polykup and Ultimate Car Care. The NJAOA says it has been monitoring multiple matters involving the businesses and has encouraged vehicle owners to report incidents they believe warrant further review. The organization maintains that documenting such complaints is important to ensuring transparency and accountability within the automotive service industry.
In a separate matter, the NJAOA has also accused Polyak and Gutwill of improperly managing an Acura NSX EV conversion project for a 90-year-old customer. According to the association, the project involved the installation of recalled battery packs that allegedly presented potential fire hazards. The organization further claims that the vehicle was eventually returned to the customer in poor condition despite a court directive concerning the matter. Those allegations remain separate from the reported Smart Fortwo Cabrio incident but form part of the NJAOA’s broader concerns regarding the businesses’ operations.
As of the time of publication, neither Samuel Polyak nor David Gutwill has issued a public statement responding to the allegations concerning the Smart Fortwo Cabrio. No public court findings regarding these latest claims have been announced, and any investigation by law enforcement authorities would determine what, if any, further action is appropriate. The allegations described by the NJAOA have not been independently verified within this report.
The NJAOA continues to encourage vehicle owners who believe their automobiles may have been driven or otherwise used without authorization to contact the association or report the matter directly to local law enforcement. The organization says that timely reporting may assist investigators in reviewing evidence and determining whether additional complaints are connected. The matter remains subject to any review or investigation that authorities may choose to undertake.
