How to Choose a Web Designer for Your Small Business
To choose a web designer for a small business, look for someone who asks how you win work before they talk about colours, and who can show you live sites that work well on a phone. Their quote should also spell out what happens after launch. Price and portfolio matter, but on their own they don’t tell you much.
This guide covers what to sort out before you start, the different kinds of providers, the questions worth asking, how to compare quotes and the red flags to watch for.
We’re the team at System Surfer, and we often talk to owners whose website looked great on launch day and then brought in very little. Most of the time the problem goes back to choices made before any design work started.
Work out what the website needs to do first
The business.gov.au guide to setting up a business website starts with the same step: decide what you want the site to achieve. For most local service businesses that comes down to something specific, like more calls, more quote requests or more online bookings.
Having that written down before you contact anyone makes every later decision easier. It also shows you quickly which designers are listening. If you say you want more quote requests and the reply is all about animations and colour palettes, they’re answering a different question.
It also helps to know a few things before the first conversation:
- what you’ll supply yourself, such as photos, wording and your logo
- which services and areas you most want to be found for
- how your customers prefer to get in touch, whether by phone, form or online booking
- who will look after the site once it’s live
Know who you’re actually hiring
Job titles in this industry overlap a lot, so ask what someone actually does rather than going by what they call themselves. Broadly, the options fall into three groups.
Freelance designers
A freelancer is often the cheapest option, and you deal with one person the whole way through. The trade off is capacity. If they’re sick, booked out or move on to other work, updates and fixes can stall, so it’s worth asking who covers for them.
Agencies and studios
An agency usually has designers, developers and someone looking after search, so more of the work can be done in house. You’ll generally pay more, and on a small project you may end up dealing with an account manager rather than the person building your site.
Managed website services
Some providers build the site and then look after it for a monthly fee, with hosting, updates and changes included. This suits owners who don’t want to deal with the technical side at all. As with any option, check exactly what the fee covers and compare the total cost over a few years.
Check their past work properly
Look at live sites on your phone
Screenshots in a portfolio can hide a lot. Ask for links to live sites and open them on your own phone, because that’s how most of your customers will see your site. ACMA’s research into how Australians use the internet found 97% of adults used a mobile phone to go online in 2025.
Check that pages load quickly, the text is easy to read without zooming and the phone number can be tapped. If their examples are slow or awkward on a phone, yours probably will be too.
Look for businesses like yours
A designer who mostly builds sites for cafes and fashion labels may not know how a plumber, physio or cleaner wins work. Look for examples from local service businesses, and ask what each of those sites was built to achieve.
Good designers will talk about how a site performs, not just how it looks. If they tell you a client gets more enquiries since the new site went live, ask how they know.
Read their reviews, then check their own website
Independent reviews on their Google Business Profile tell you more than hand picked testimonials on their website. Read the low ratings too, and look at how the business responded to them.
Their own website is worth a close look as well. If it’s slow, dated or hard to get in touch through, that’s a fair preview of the attention your site will get.
Questions to ask a web designer before you choose
About the process
- Who will I deal with day to day, and who actually builds the site?
- What do you need from me, and by when?
- How long will it take, and what usually causes delays?
- How many rounds of changes are included before launch?
About the website itself
- How will the site work on mobile, and how do you test it?
- What search basics are included, such as page titles, meta descriptions and setting up my business profile?
- Where do enquiries go when someone fills in a form, and how will I know straight away?
- What happens when a customer calls from the site and I can’t pick up?
The last two often get overlooked. A site can look great and still lose work if form enquiries land in an inbox nobody checks, or missed calls never get a reply.
About life after launch
- Who looks after hosting, security updates and backups?
- If I need a change, who makes it, how quickly, and what does it cost?
- Is support included, and will it come from the person who built the site?
The business.gov.au guide notes that self hosted sites need the latest security patches applied, and recommends a strong password with two factor authentication turned on. Ask your designer who will be responsible for each of these once the site is live.
How to compare web design quotes
Send the same brief to each designer you’re considering, so every quote covers the same work. Then compare what’s included rather than just the bottom line. Look for:
- the number of pages, and what it costs to add more later
- whether they write the wording or leave it to you
- photos, and whether any stock images carry ongoing licence fees
- hosting, domain and business email setup
- search setup, including your business profile
- support and changes after launch
Pricing models vary too. Some providers charge a single upfront price for the build and bill hosting and changes separately. Others charge a monthly fee that covers the build and everything after it. Neither is better by default, so work out what each would cost you over two or three years, including the changes you’re likely to need.
Red flags to watch for
- Guaranteed rankings. Google’s own advice on hiring help with search is that no one can guarantee a #1 ranking. A promise like that usually means the provider is targeting searches nobody makes.
- No live examples. Mockups and screenshots aren’t enough to judge how a site actually works.
- A one line quote. A single figure with no breakdown leaves a lot of room for surprises later.
- Pressure to decide on the spot. A good provider will give you time to compare.
- No questions about your customers. If they don’t ask how you get work, they can’t build a site to help you win more of it.
- Vague answers about after launch. You should know exactly who to contact when something breaks.
Does it matter if they’re local?
Not as much as it used to, as plenty of good work is done remotely. It matters more that they’re easy to reach during your business hours and understand how Australian customers search. Familiarity with Australian rules, such as those around texting and emailing customers, is also useful if your site will send follow ups or review requests.
Making the final call
Once you’ve narrowed it down to two or three options, the choice usually comes down to who understood your business best and gave you the clearest answers. The cheapest quote can end up costing more if the site needs fixing or rebuilding within a year or two.
It’s worth going with the provider who asked the most about how you win work and could explain, without hedging, what happens once the site is live. That tells you far more about how your website will perform than any mockup.
FAQs
What questions should I ask a web designer?
Ask who you’ll deal with, what the quote includes, how the site will work on mobile and where enquiries go. Also ask who looks after hosting, updates and changes after launch, and what those cost.
Should I use a freelancer or an agency for my website?
A freelancer is usually cheaper and more personal, while an agency has more people and services in house. For a small local business, the better choice is whoever understands how you win work and can support the site after launch.
What’s the difference between a web designer and a web developer?
A designer focuses on how the site looks and how people move through it, while a developer builds how it works. Many small business providers do both, so ask exactly what’s covered in your quote.
Can I build my own small business website instead?
Yes, DIY website builders make it possible. The trade off is your time, plus the ongoing work of keeping the site fast, secure, mobile friendly and set up for search, which is where many owners end up asking for help.